Around The Block

Exploring the 13 most overvalued players in the NBA, featuring De’Aaron Fox’s new contract with the Spurs

Exploring the 13 Most Overvalued Players in the NBA: De’Aaron Fox and Beyond

The NBA’s landscape is shaped as much by blockbuster trades and jaw-dropping plays as it is by eye-watering contracts. As team owners and general managers continue to bet big on talent, some deals inevitably raise eyebrows and invite debate about value for money. De’Aaron Fox’s recent extension with the San Antonio Spurs has provided fresh fuel for this ongoing discussion, shining a spotlight on the league’s most overvalued players heading into the 2025-26 season.

De’Aaron Fox’s Blockbuster Spurs Deal

The San Antonio Spurs turned heads by handing point guard De’Aaron Fox a four-year, $229 million extension—an average of $57.25 million per season, with a staggering $51 million salary in the first year. Once this deal kicks in for the 2026-27 season, Fox will become the 17th highest-paid player in the NBA. To put this in perspective, Fox’s deal edges out even superstar Luka Doncic’s new contract. A front-office source remarked, “When a player hasn’t matched up to the top tier by accolades, it’s a massive risk to put them in this salary bracket.”

The Spurs weren’t shy about their intention to pair Fox with franchise centerpiece Victor Wembanyama; however, the duo’s run was cut short after just five games due to Wemby’s season-ending injury. Now, San Antonio must ponder the wisdom of maxing out Fox’s contract, especially after securing a promising rookie point guard, Dylan Harper, in the draft—a move that underscores delicate roster dynamics moving forward.

Numbers Don’t Lie—But Context Matters

Fox boasts undeniable talent but sits in an awkward salary class. At 27, he’s a one-time NBA All-Star and made Third-Team All-NBA in 2023, yet he has only appeared in one playoff series. While Hoops Hype ranks him as the ninth-best point guard for next season, other experts see him as more of a top-30 player overall. As one league analyst explained, “Speed and ball-handling are Fox’s forte, but the lack of shooting efficiency and playoff experience are concerns. That’s a lot of money for what’s still mostly potential.”

The 13 Most Overvalued NBA Contracts

Fox’s new deal is just one example. Here are the 13 players generating the most debate:

Joel Embiid (Philadelphia 76ers) – 4 years, $243 million.
Hobbled by persistent injuries, Embiid’s prime could be ticking away before he delivers a real postseason run. “Philly’s hands are tied. If Embiid can’t bounce back, this could become the ultimate cap anchor,” says an Eastern Conference exec.
Paul George (Philadelphia 76ers) – 3 years, $162.2 million.
Once prized for two-way play, George now faces persistent health setbacks, leaving the 76ers scrambling for reliable star power.
Jerami Grant (Portland Trail Blazers) – 3 years, $102.6 million.
Grant’s game has slipped, especially around the rim, and Portland’s rebuilding mode leaves his contract without a clear role or takers.
Dejounte Murray (New Orleans Pelicans) – 3 years, $96.7 million.
An inefficiency-prone scorer and not quite the defender he’s billed as, Murray now faces a tough road back from a major Achilles tear.
Zach LaVine (Sacramento Kings) – 2 years, $96.4 million.
Despite elite shooting numbers, LaVine’s defensive lapses, decision-making, and injury history dampen his market value.
Jalen Green (Phoenix Suns) – 3 years, $105.3 million.
A skilled scorer but shaky all-around contributor, Green’s inconsistency led Houston to move on without regret.
Patrick Williams (Chicago Bulls) – 4 years, $72 million.
Paid more for potential than production, Williams had his worst season post-extension, stagnating in a rebuilding Bulls squad.
Jordan Poole (New Orleans Pelicans) – 2 years, $65.8 million.
Poole’s scoring chops are clear, but his erratic play and murky fit give the Pelicans little confidence in a return on investment.
Immanuel Quickley (Toronto Raptors) – 4 years, $130 million.
Toronto gambled big after the OG Anunoby trade, but Quickley’s injuries and underwhelming performances have yet to justify the contract.
Devin Booker (Phoenix Suns) – 5 years, $316 million.
Top-20 league-wide, not quite a superstar. The Suns are betting Booker’s prime will stretch into his 30s, but the back end of this deal could restrict team-building options.
Jamal Murray (Denver Nuggets) – 4 years, $207.8 million.
An essential playoff performer, but Murray’s lack of All-Star selections and recent playoffs dip raise questions about long-term returns.
Jaylen Brown (Boston Celtics) – 4 years, $236 million.
Finals MVP credentials secure Brown’s value in Boston lore, but with Tatum sidelined, his massive extension could become a focal point in the Celtics’ recalibration.
De’Aaron Fox (San Antonio Spurs) – 4 years, $229 million.
The Spurs have paid up despite overlapping talent and shaky outside shooting in their backcourt. “Sometimes teams pay for the idea of star power, not just the stats,” a Western Conference scout reflected.

Diverse Perspectives and A Shifting NBA Economy

Owners can afford these contracts—Peter Holt bought the Spurs for $75 million in the late 90s and the franchise is now valued at billions. But with the NBA’s new “second apron” rules, overcommitting to borderline stars limits flexibility to build a true contender. “Teams can’t just keep stacking max contracts on guys outside the superstar circle. The penalties are steeper now than ever,” observed a salary cap specialist.

At the same time, the player empowerment era means stars (and their agents) expect maximum leverage. “Franchise value is soaring because of player-driven interest,” notes one veteran agent. “Teams pay because it’s the cost of doing business.”

Looking Ahead

The arms race for talent and buzz has never been more expensive. Only time will tell which contracts become bargain investments and which hang like anchors on the NBA’s financial landscape. For now, the conversation about value, risk, and reward remains front and center every time the free agency frenzy begins anew.

Source: www.sbnation.com